Skip to main content

  • Home
  • Who We Are 
    • Our Team
    • Our Philosophy
    • Our Process
  • Our Services 
    • Retirement Planning
  • Podcasts
  • Blog
  • Contact

    You are here

  1. Home
  2. Blogs
  3. How Wall Street Lies To You (Legally)

How Wall Street Lies To You (Legally)

Submitted by Axios Capital Strategies on November 28th, 2020
  • Share on Facebook
  • Facebook Like
  • Linkedin Share Button
 

Average Return vs. Actual Returns

How many times have you looked at the average returns for a mutual fund or ETF (exchange traded fund), or perhaps a money manager? You know how it goes: you are shown the 1-year, 3-year, 5-year, 10-year, and “since inception” average returns. We all tend to make decisions based on historical returns even though we know “past performance is no predictor or guarantee of future results.” While this is generally a poor metric to judge a portfolio by, especially if it’s the only one being used, this post isn’t how to quantify and qualify different financial vehicles.

There’s another disclosure that’s usually overlooked. At the bottom, in fine print, is often some language like, “Actual performance may differ.”

Actual performance? Isn’t that what we were looking at?

Sadly, no. Average returns and actual returns are indeed different, and materially so. Let’s take a quick, if extreme, example to illustrate the point.

Assume you are looking at a portfolio’s history, and it advertises an annual average of 0% per year over the past 4 years. The year-by-year returns are as follows:

Portfolio Return
Year 1 50%  
Year 2 -50%
Year 3 50%
Year 4 -50%
 

Now, what is the annual average return? Zero, right? (50 + -50 + 50 + -50)/4 = 0. Right. This is called an arithmetic mean, just like you learned in middle school. This is also what mutual funds and money managers show you as their past performance.

 

Portfolio Return

Year 1

50%

Year 2

-50%

Year 3

50%

Year 4

-50%

Average

0%

 

If we put $100,000 into this portfolio four years ago, and the average is 0% per year, then we would have $100,000 now, right? A reasonable person would presume this, since that’s what the literature, even prospectuses, advertise. Sadly, it’s trickier than that. Let’s track the dollar value changes with the same year-by-year returns, starting with the $100,000 opening value.

Portfolio Return

End of Year Value

Year 1

50%

$ 150,000

Year 2

-50%

$ 75,000

Year 3

50%

$ 112,500

Year 4

-50%

$ 56,250

Average      0%

Actual Cumm. Return      -43.75%

 

If you have to spend a few minutes studying the difference, we understand. It seems like a brainteaser when you first learn the difference between average and actual returns. Even though the average return of this portfolio really is 0%, the actual cumulative return is -43.75%! Wall Street is not required to show you the actual returns, what the dollar amount actually grew (or declined) to. That is the definition of actual returns. What do you value more when evaluating a financial instrument? We thought so.

The actual return is called a “geometric mean,” and is much more telling when investigating financial tools, especially since it takes into account the effects of compounding. While this is an extreme example to illustrate the principle, the concept is accurately portrayed. Over time, even a difference of 1-2% between average and actual returns can mean a difference of tens to hundreds of thousands of dollars in your account value.

The next time you read the fine print and find the disclosure that “actual returns may differ,” just know that they almost certainly will differ, and that difference can be quite dramatic. Why does Wall Street only show us the average return in their material* Because it’s almost always higher than the actual returns of their products or portfolios.

Here’s a longer-term, less dramatic example.

 

Portfolio Return

End of Year Value

Year 1

10%

$                                    110,000.00

Year 2

-5%

$                                    104,500.00

Year 3

5%

$                                    109,725.00

Year 4

-10%

$                                      98,752.50

Year 5

20%

$                                    118,503.00

Year 6

-10%

$                                    106,652.70

Year 7

10%

$                                    117,317.97

Year 8

-15%

$                                      99,720.27

Year 9

15%

$                                    114,678.32

Year 10

-20%

$                                      91,742.65

Average      0%

Actual Cumm. Return.             -8.26%

 

Even though there’s nearly a $9,000 loss over the ten-year example period, the average return, what you would see in the sales literature, is 0%. Forgive us, but even though this is “legal” to advertise as such, we can’t help but feel it’s misleading.

When Are Average and Actual Returns Equal?

When there are all positive years or periods, the average and actual returns match. When there are periods of no negative returns (but at least one 0% year, neither negative nor positive), then the actual and average returns are very close, bringing more transparent historical returns to the surface. This is one reason we usually advocate an absolute return strategy as opposed to a relative return strategy, especially with money that really matters . . . you know, like retirement money—money you have to make last rest of your life.

Happily, there are many retirement strategies that eliminate downside market movements in your retirement strategies while still participating in upward market movements, thus allowing your average and actual performance to come closer in alignment. After all, isn’t what the money actually grew to (actual return) more important that the arithmetic percentage average?

Yeah. It is.

Dig deeper when you look at historical performance numbers and you might be surprised.

Tags:
  • 401K
  • annuity
  • difference between actual and average returns
  • How to calculate rate of return
  • IRA
  • LIRP
  • rate of return
  • retirement
  • Roth 401K
  • Roth IRA
  • social security
  • tax-free retirement
  • what is actual return
  • what is average return

Recent Blog Posts

  • When Should You Claim Your Social Security?
  • Tax-free Retirement - Part 4 - Utilizing a Life Insurance Retirement Plan (LIRP) As Part of a Tax-free Retirement
  • Tax-free Retirement - Part 3 - Utilizing a Life Insurance Retirement Plan (LIRP) As Part of a Tax-free Retirement

Archived Blog

  • February 2021 (2)
  • January 2021 (4)
  • December 2020 (7)
  • November 2020 (3)

Categories

  • 401K (5)
  • annuity (3)
  • COVID-19 (1)
  • difference between actual and average returns (1)
  • How to calculate rate of return (1)
  • IRA (4)
  • Life Insurance Retirement Plan (3)
  • LIRP (7)
  • provisional income (6)
  • qualified plans (1)
  • rate of return (1)
  • retirement (9)
  • retirement income (8)
  • retirement planning (8)
  • Roth 401K (7)
  • Roth IRA (5)
  • social security (5)
  • tax deferral (1)
  • tax free income (1)
  • tax free retirement (5)
  • tax-deferred (2)
  • tax-free retirement (4)
  • taxed (1)
  • taxes (2)
  • TSP (2)
  • what is actual return (1)
  • what is average return (1)

Contact Us

Our commitment to your financial goals brings confidence and clarity to your future.

 

Phone: 435.868.3160
Fax: 435.275.4194

Email: kcooper@axioscapital.com

321 N Mall Dr, Building R, St George, UT 84790

Get Directions

10808 S River Front Pkwy, Suite 300, South Jordan, UT 84095

Get Directions

5550 Painted Mirage Rd, Suite 320, Las Vegas, NV 89149

Get Directions

   

 

 

  • Sitemap
  • Legal, privacy, copyright and trademark information

The information contained on this website is for informational purposes only, and does not constitute a solicitation or sale of any financial or insurance instrument or vehicle. Always consult with independent financial, legal, and tax advisors prior to implementing any strategy. The information contained on this website is believed to be accurate, but not warranteed to be so. Axios Capital Strategies (ACS) will not be held liable for your usage of the information on this site. The information on this site is only intended for those who reside in states where ACS and/or its agents are licensed to do business.

Licensed Insurance Professional. Respond and learn how insurance and annuities can positively impact your retirement. This material has been provided by a licensed insurance professional for informational and educational purposes only and is not endorsed or affiliated with the Social Security Administration or any government agency. It is not intended to provide, and should not be relied upon for, accounting, legal, tax, or investment advice.

 

 

© 2021 Axios Capital Strategies. All rights reserved.

Website Design For Financial Services Professionals